Acquired Situational Narcissism
by
Stephen Sherrill [NY Times]
We
all know that movie stars, professional athletes, rich people and
politicians
often act like complete jackasses, but Robert B. Millman, professor of
psychiatry at Cornell Medical School and the medical adviser to Major
League
Baseball, thinks he knows why. The cause, he says, is acquired
situational
narcissism, a psychological dysfunction that Millman was the first to
identify
and that he treats in his celebrity patients.
Classical narcissism, a personality disorder whose symptoms
include
lack of empathy, grandiose fantasies, excessive need for approval,
rage,
social isolation and depression, has been well mapped by the
psychoanalytical
community. It begins, conventional theory has it, because of an uneven
transition between infancy, when we're all natural narcissists, and age
4, when a more realistic view of the world should be developing.
People who aspire to stardom tend to be more narcissistic than
others,
but they don't develop a true narcissistic personality disorder until
they
begin to achieve success: the first platinum album, the first
appearance
in Vanity Fair's ''Young Hollywood'' issue, the first public fling with
Winona Ryder.
Because the onset occurs well after childhood, celebrity
narcissism
isn't covered by the textbook definition of the condition.
''Psychoanalytic
literature is filled with jargon about how narcissism happens really
early,''
says Millman, ''but I realized that given the right situation, it could
happen much later.'' That's the Acquisition.
The Situation is fame, money and, even more, the
pheromone-like power
of fame and money. ''When a billionaire or a celebrity walks into a
room,''
says Millman, ''everyone looks at him. He's a prince. He has the power
to change your life, and everyone is very conscious of that. So they're
drawn to this person. What happens is that he gets so used to everyone
looking at him that he stops looking back at them.''
Before the celebrity knows it, he's having grandiose
fantasies, he can't
feel empathy, he's full of rage, she's starring in ''Glitter.'' The
celebrity
has begun to share all the symptoms of severe narcissists.
But there are a few important differences. Both groups suffer
from a
distorted view of their place in the world, but the tension in the
early-developing
narcissist is more self-contained. In the acquired situational
narcissist,
it is also fed by people who surround him.
Even worse, the view of the
world the acquired situational narcissist is getting is, when you think
about it, quite reasonable. ''They are different,'' says Millman.
''They're
not normal. And why would they feel normal when every person in the
world
who deals with them treats them as if they're not?''
This includes the celebrity's usual planetary system of
assistants,
publicists, agents, lawyers and groupies. But it also includes us, the
public. We're all complicit in acquired situational narcissism. ''We've
created it,'' says Millman. ''They're just responding to us.''
We're drawn to stars because they're stars, but we also want
to be assured
that something in them is still ''normal,'' that, really, they're just
like you and me. This leads to magazine scoops like, ''On Saturday
nights,
Julia Roberts loves to just stay at home and churn her own butter.''
But there's also a thrill when they mess up, as they
inevitably do.
Who doesn't enjoy reading in The National Enquirer about someone
''buying
$5,000 chips and downing house drinks. . . . He was down about $70,000
and he got louder, picking on the poor dealer, saying, 'Would it kill
ya
to deal a [expletive] blackjack once in a while?''' That was Ben
Affleck,
God bless him.
So why is acquired situational narcissism a problem? It's not,
for us
or for E! or for the tabloids or for VH1's ''Behind the Music.''
It is,
however, for the acquired situational narcissists. Their marriages fall
apart, they make lousy parents, they take copious quantities of drugs,
they get into trouble with the law. ''Because they truly don't believe
the world is real,'' Millman says, ''they begin to think they're
invulnerable.
Some even risk their lives, since the world can't hurt them if it's not
real.''
The goal of treating acquired situational narcissists can't be
to convince
them that they're normal. They're not, and people are never going to
treat
them as if they are. Also, narcissists don't seek treatment for
narcissism.
They seek treatments for the symptoms their narcissism causes, like
depression,
anxiety and substance abuse.
''What I do is talk about the depression,'' says Millman, who
has treated
actors, politicians and athletes (as well as regular, nonfamous
people),
''because that's what's really bothering them. And then, in passing,
you
gently and nicely and with love tell them how they have this
narcissistic
problem.''
Sometimes the narcissists are O.K. with that, and sometimes
they're not. ''A number of people never come back,'' Millman says.
The term doesn't appear yet in the psychiatric literature, but
it will
be included in the next edition of ''Substance Abuse: A Comprehensive
Textbook,''
which Millman co-edits and which is the definitive guide to the field
of
substance abuse.
And there's always word of mouth. ''Last night I had
dinner
with this old friend of mine'' - a celebrity - ''who was actually one
of
the inspirations for the idea,'' says Millman. ''He thought it was so
remarkable,
because it explained his behavior. He said, 'I have high-class
problems!'
He just couldn't stop talking about it.''
-------
New
York Times, Dec. 9, 2001
Copyright
2001 The New York Times Company
~ ~ ~
related
page:**ego /
narcissism......ego / narcissism 2 :
quotes articles books
related article:**Ego
and Creativity
~ ~ ~
|